Charlie Manuel frequently makes poor strategic decisions. The 11-million dollar scoreboard in left field would probably do a similar job. We guarantee a post analyzing Manuel's decisions for every Phillies game. Please click on our aliases below to email us.

Blog Archive

95% Phillies, 4% Eagles/Flyers/Sixers/Big Five, 1% Nonsense .... Contact us: Scott Graham ~ Andy Musser

Saturday, December 8, 2012

Phillies obtain Michael Young

Earlier today, I posted about the Ben Revere trade that the Phillies made earlier this week, and briefly touched on the possibility of the Phils trading for Michael Young.  Young, 36, has played for the Texas Rangers for 13 seasons.  In 2012, Young had a sub-par season on the way to accumulating a -2.4 rWAR.  I mentioned earlier how I wasn't thrilled about the Phillies pursuing Young, and I'm not satisfied now that they made the deal.

I don't think it will be hard for Young to "earn" his $6 million (the Rangers are paying $10 million of the $16 million he's due in 2013).  Each win is worth about 4-5 million dollars, so Young will need to be slightly over a 1 WAR player.  Should he play mostly 3B, his just filling in the position will give him decent "value", and should he help him be "worth" what the Phillies are paying him.  My concern isn't about the money the Phils are spending on him.  I'm more concerned about just how highly the Phillies valued him and what they gave up to get him.

I'm not even talking about Josh Lindblom, whom the Phillies received in the Shane Victorino trade.  Lindblom is nothing special to me, and I never really understood the hype.  I'm more upset that the Phillies traded Lisalverto Bonilla.  I don't even know who he is, and his being dealt bothers me.  While he's merely a AA reliever, which in itself suggests there's not a high ceiling for him, his minor league numbers are encouraging.  Yes, he's still got a ways to go before reaching the majors, but the guy has a cumulative 9.3 K/9 to go with a 2.7 BB/9 in the minors.  This past season in Reading, Bonilla struck out 12.5/9 IP (yes, in just 33 innings), but walked 4.6/9 IP over that same time span.

I'm not sure this trade is anything to be furious about, but it's just not encouraging to see the types of players that the Phillies value/consider disposable.  It seems to imply that they still just don't get the sabermetric side of things.  

I certainly hope the Phillies aren't done dealing yet, or it will be a painful season to be a Phillies fan.  

By the way, the Phillies' gap in starting rotation dominance is quickly closing as the Nationals have a nice trio of their own in Strasburg, Gonzalez, and Haren.  Combine this with offensive talent like Ryan Zimmerman, Jayson Werth, Mike Morse, Bryce Harper, Denard Span, and bullpen arms like Clippard, Storen, and Stammen, and it's clear the Phillies are going to have their hands full for years to come.  

14 comments:

Robby Bonfire said...

Way to go, Phillies, another typical one step forward, three steps backward, short-term patching, myopic vision trade. Of course we understand they are trying to "Win it for Charlie" in his last go-round. Wow, is that funny or what, mortgage more of the future to celebrate the hideous incompetence of the present and recent past?

Major surprise if the Phillies escape the divisional basement, next season. You can just hear the bones creaking and the injuries piling up, already. Can Chase start in 160 games, Charlie? Hell, let's go for it, right? What's a little burn-out between friends?

Robby Bonfire said...

.250, 18 home runs, 70 RBI's, D.L. twice = I'm so excited!

Robby Bonfire said...

Good Gawd, Adams is 34, and Lannan is the worst starter in the N.L. vs. the Phillies (5 1/2+ ERA and 3-13 career record) who, apparently don't want to beat him up any more.

Can somebody just put a straitjacket on Amaro? He is a brush fire about to sweep down the entire canyon.

This horse race between the Phillies and the Yankees to see which franchise can field the oldest team in baseball history in 2013, is becoming ~fascinating,~ for lack of a more disparaging word.

Robby Bonfire said...

Polanco to Miami? Oh, "The Horror!"

Seriously, three thoughts. 1. Baseball desperately needs to contract, too many AA and AAA grunts and DH types hanging on an extra 3-5 years - for the money - not for any contribution they can make, because they have none to give.

2. What the puck is Miami's problem? This is just about the most absurd signing of the last decade. This man is physically beaten to a pulp, old by baseball standards, and spent, to where he is not even a one-dimensional "role player" any more. How awful, today, to wake up if you're a Marlins fan, to get the news of this signing. "Stopgap City" is what they should rename Miami.

And 3., as I've observed before, old guys get to hang on because teams, for the most part, don't want to bring up kids 18-21, and lose them to Free Agency in just six years at their career peak. This is an awful corner MLB has painted itself into, the FA eligibility requirement should kick in when players turn 30, so that dozens of budding young careers are not forestalled until their mid-20's. (See: Philadelphia Phillies, for the most egregious textbook cases on that one.)

When they crapper the DH, and change the FA qualifier to age 30, guess what, we who support the game get a much better product. As it now stands, with too many teams, a cruddy FA qualifier, and with the idiot DH (Tailor made for washed-up greybeards) we are being shafted for the price we are paying to keep this TV-ratings numbers racket going.

hk said...

"I don't think it will be hard for Young to "earn" his $6 million (the Rangers are paying $10 million of the $16 million he's due in 2013). Each win is worth about 4-5 million dollars, so Young will need to be slightly over a 1 WAR player."

I could not disagree with this comment more for the following reasons:

1. The $4M-$5M per win is used to assess the value of a free agent, not a player acquired in trade. I'm not sure Young will provide enough WAR to be worth parting with Bonilla, much less to be worth getting $6M.

2. I think that Fangraphs' assessment of $/WAR is bull**** because moves are not made in a vacuum. In this case, Young should not be compared to a replacement level player, he should be compared to Kevin Frandsen because Young is taking PT from Frandsen. To be worth the $6M plus the prospect traded, Young will have to produce more than 1.2 to 1.5 WAR. To me, he'll have to produce ~3.5 WAR, which is ~2.0 WAR more than the ~1.5 WAR I would expect Frandsen to produce in 400-500 PA's at 3B, to be worth the price.

3. Last year, without the 21.7 Replacement Runs Above Replacement - I know that sounds redundant - that Young received from Ron Washington insanely giving him 611 PA's, Young produced -34.8 RAR (or 34.8 RBR Runs Below Replacement). I just don't see him rebounding enough in 2013 to produce the WAR necessary to justify the cost and the opportunity cost (taking the PA's away from Frandsen).

Scott Graham said...

Fair enough. I tried to dial back my anger that the Phillies traded for Michael Young. I don't like him. I don't like that the Phillies like him. I just got the feeling I was being too critical, and tried to temper my... temper.


I don't think he's going to be good for the Phils. I probably should have looked at it more like Young over Frandsen and Young's contract over Frandsen's contract, but instead I looked at it more like, Frandsen vs. his contract.

hk said...

"By the way, the Phillies' gap in starting rotation dominance is quickly closing as the Nationals have a nice trio of their own in Strasburg, Gonzalez, and Haren."

Now, there's a comment with which I wholeheartedly agree. When the Phils traded Worley for Revere to fill CF instead of paying $15M per year to Upton or Bourn, I figured the next play was to sign one of the top free agent SP's, preferably Anibal Sanchez, but I would have been okay with Edwin Jackson. Instead of giving $13M per year to Edwin, they pissed away $14.5M + Bonilla on Young, Adams and Lannan.

Robby Bonfire said...

How I wish MLB would contract the Phillies and one other dumpy franchise and bring the A's back to Philadelphia which would solve the Bay Area crowed tenancy debacle.

Imagine, the A's left Philadelphia for Cowtown, than for Jerry Brown Country, for lack of a better metaphore, and now are playing it like a bunch of homeless Gypsies just running around in circles. Maybe UCLA can resurrect its "Tent City" of the '80's for them and let them use Jackie Robinson Stadium, capacity 2500.

One lost franchise, Saber skills GM, or not. Sort of like the Phillies are a lost organization, except the Phillies do have a great fan base, which the A's forfeited, back in the Dark Ages, at the "behest" of the Yankees. (Don't get me started as regards the Yankees screwing both the A's and the Phillies, way back when.)

Anonymous said...

игровые автоматы играть бес [url=http://nananntetiivarback.narod.ru/280.html]первое онлайн казино[/url] игровые автоматы capcom , [url=http://nananntetiivarback.narod.ru/490.html]игровые автоматы елена играть бесплатно шарики[/url] игровые автоматы демо 2012 , [url=http://nananntetiivarback.narod.ru/462.html]игровые автоматы 15 линейные играть бесплатно гонки[/url] игровые автоматы online ярославль , [url=http://nananntetiivarback.narod.ru/378.html]игровые автоматы сан лайт казино[/url] игровые автоматы без депозита , [url=http://nananntetiivarback.narod.ru/574.html]игровые автоматы эмулятор белатра[/url]

Anonymous said...

игровые автоматы онлайн елена казино [url=http://metifidesaslim.narod.ru/file448.html]создать интернет казино бесплатно[/url] игровые автоматы скачать бесплатно на компьютер для девочек , [url=http://metifidesaslim.narod.ru/file350.html]lucky roger игровой автомат[/url] интернет рулетка онлайн игра , [url=http://metifidesaslim.narod.ru/file98.html]покер онлайн бесплатно без регистрации[/url] слот автоматы фрукты , [url=http://metifidesaslim.narod.ru/file154.html]игровой автомат queen of hearts[/url] онлайн покер в россии

Anonymous said...

слот автоматы где находятся [url=http://tiotaversiwanad.narod.ru/topic154.html]игровые автоматы печки онлайн[/url] игровые автоматы онлайн бесплатно без регистрации резидент , [url=http://tiotaversiwanad.narod.ru/topic660.html]азартные игры волшебников скачать бесплатно[/url] интернет казино играть на деньги , [url=http://tiotaversiwanad.narod.ru/topic154.html]игровые автоматы печки онлайн[/url] интернет казино azartplay , [url=http://tiotaversiwanad.narod.ru/topic528.html]игровой автомат sphinx[/url] бесплатные игровые автоматы книжки , [url=http://tiotaversiwanad.narod.ru/topic330.html]казино гранд онлайн бесплатно[/url]

Anonymous said...

игровой автомат stacker [url=http://pacnaboobravtobrod.narod.ru/bigazart-onlayn-kazino.html]bigazart онлайн казино[/url] азартные игры торрент , [url=http://pacnaboobravtobrod.narod.ru/skachat-igrovoy-avtomat-rezident-besplatno.html]скачать игровой автомат резидент бесплатно[/url] игровые автоматы резидент играть онлайн бесплатно гонки , [url=http://pacnaboobravtobrod.narod.ru/striptiz-poker-onlayn.html]стриптиз покер онлайн[/url] игровые автоматы бесплатно серии , [url=http://pacnaboobravtobrod.narod.ru/igri-onlayn-poker-nardi.html]игры онлайн покер нарды[/url] игровые автоматы 777 азартные , [url=http://pacnaboobravtobrod.narod.ru/igrovie-avtomati-igrat-ultra-hot.html]игровые автоматы играть ultra hot[/url]

Poker Bonus said...

Very fine article and very useful for me and for other readers too. You are doing outstanding work here. Keep posting in new 2014 year.
--------------
Free poker money
No deposit online poker bonus
Texas holdem online free
An interesting issue for those who would like to start playing online poker for real money without their own contribution. This is a pretty good way to make money on the Internet (you have to play well, of course). This is the only real method known to me (in a rather short period of time can be a lot of gain) to earn through the internet.
Texas holdem bonuses link
our free time poker money bankrolls
Bonusy za darmo bez ryzyka
Follow the instructions given on PokerStrategy and get a free $ 50 to play, at what we choose. I would recommend because poker is a fun, addictive game (cool rozrywak) and the way you earn.
Party Poker is the leading site for players from Europe, which every day attracts hundreds of thousands of players to participate in promotions tournaments and VIP loyalty program. New players who join Party Poker through our site may select one of the Party Poker Bonus: 100% bonus to the amount of the first payment made with a value up to $ 500 and a bonus of $ 25 Below are details on both proposals, as well as information regarding the Party Poker VIP rewards, so you can get a cash refund or instant poker bonuses awarded only to collect Party Points.
Poker money bonuses - Start capital for free texas holdem online - Poker net online
www.freepokermoney.eu

No Deposit Bonus Poker said...

Your latest article is just good. I hope we read here more in new 2014 year and me ( i am poker player who play no deposit bonus ). So, update this uniqe blog often.
--------------
No deposit money bonuses
Gratis Poker sin deposito
Texas holdem poker online
Many players know that Pokerstars is the lone leader when it comes to the biggest poker sites in the world. However, few people know that this room offers your first deposit bonus in three parts . Amazing software , the largest selection of cash games , the largest poker tournament list - these are just a few advantages in favor of the fact that you simply have to check this poker room personally . To start your 3-piece bonus , up to a total amount of $ 600 ( you're at it until 90 days) select - Marketing Code from the " How did you hear about the PokerStars " during the registration process . In the window enter the marketing code - PSP3108 . When you deposit using the code STARS600 - in each of the three cases, pay money , use this code. Read our detailed review on Pokerstars here .
No deposit money Computer for Omaha Poker game
www.laptops-for-sale.org where we can play poker bonus.
Bonus for FullTiltFull Tilt Poker to be from 2012 to PokerStars. This means that you can expect there to promote and top-notch customer service . By registering an account and making a deposit you will receive a bonus of 100 % up to $ 600 . The cool thing is that you can separate into three deposits , which means that you do not need to immediately pay the entire amount . To use the whole amount available for bonus is 60 days. Bonus must be activated after the own deposit!
23 inch tv under 300
TV Program learn High Stakes Poker
www.viteo.org